Menu of Original Italian Pizza in Turbotville, Pennsylvania, USA

Menu Overview

Original Italian Pizza, nestled at 37 Main St, Turbotville, PA, offers a genuine taste of traditional Italian-American pizza heritage. Their menu strikes a fine balance between classic favorites and thoughtfully crafted specialty items, ensuring a memorable experience for pizza enthusiasts and casual diners alike.

The standout feature on the menu is undoubtedly their Large Cheese Pizza. Made with fresh, high-quality mozzarella and a perfectly baked crust, it embodies a simple yet irresistible flavor profile that appeals to purists. For those seeking gluten-free options, the GlutenFree Pizza—with its dedicated gluten-free crust—is a considerate choice that doesn’t compromise on taste or texture.

The small specialty pizzas burst with distinctive flavors. The Small Tuscan Pizza combines pesto basil sauce with grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, and ripe tomatoes, creating a blend that feels both rustic and fresh. Meanwhile, the Small German Pizza boldly incorporates steak, onions, and green peppers in a rich sauce that delivers satisfying heartiness. The Small Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza layers chicken steak and crispy bacon with ranch dressing, offering a flavorful twist on a beloved comfort classic. The Buffalo Crispy Chicken Pizza stands out with its perfect balance between crispy texture and moderate sauce coverage, providing an exciting bite without overwhelming the palate.

Calzones at Original Italian Pizza deserve a special mention. The Florentine Calzone, available in both small and large sizes, delights with its savory mix of spinach, tomato, garlic, ricotta, and mozzarella—a combination that honors authentic Italian flavors with a rich, creamy finish. The Chicken Bruschetta Calzone, packed with grilled chicken and tangy tomato, is equally satisfying, wrapped in a golden, perfectly baked dough.

Chicken cheesesteak sandwiches add variety to the menu. The Philly Chicken Cheesesteak features fried onions, green peppers, and cheddar cheese, melding American sandwich traditions with a hint of Italian flair via well-balanced seasoning. Meanwhile, the Honey Mustard Chicken Cheesesteak layers bacon and provolone cheese with a sweet and tangy honey mustard, creating a nuanced flavor profile that stands out among sandwich offerings.

Customers appreciate the quality and attentiveness of the Original Italian Pizza experience. Michael Jones praises the pizza and subs, highlighting a welcome improvement in iced tea and enjoying the house-made bread—even if he feels the baked wings could use a punchier seasoning. Cassandra Christensen’s positive feedback on the flavorful wings (not excessively sauced), properly seasoned calzones, and generous pizza toppings reflects well on the kitchen’s consistency. Kim Van Horn celebrates the owner’s flexibility and willingness to customize orders, underscoring a personalized approach that enhances customer satisfaction.

Overall, Original Italian Pizza embodies the charm of a small-town pizzeria that takes its craft seriously. With a menu that respects tradition while embracing variety, attentive customer service, and freshly prepared, thoughtfully seasoned dishes, it remains a reliable and satisfying destination for pizza lovers in Turbotville and beyond.